The Meaning of Critical Mass
A discussion about the meaning and tactics of Critical Mass.
I'm reading "Critical Mass: Bicycling's Defiant Celebration" (2002, AK Press, edited by Chris Carlsson). It's an interesting collection of essays about Critical Masses that have been taking place around the world. (Critical Mass--CM-began in the early 1990s in San Francisco. It is a slow-moving bicycle ride in a city which is designed to disrupt automobile traffic.)
Chris also came to Black Planet books (in Fells Point) recently to discuss CM. He was articulate and seemed like a really nice guy. He was actually among the initial core of bicycle enthusiasts who started CM. (Chris says that no one person can claim the distinction of inventing it.) Their inspiration for the name, "Critical Mass", comes from a movie that they saw. It showed how bicyclists in normal days in Chinese cities mass in the middle of intersections. When enough have arrived they enter it, briefly cutting off motorists to get to where they need to go.
Baltimore celebrates Critical Mass on the last Friday of every month. (We meet at Charles and Redwood Streets, downtown.) For much of this year the police have been a problem. Last March they went ape-shit and arrested four riders for assault. They charged one of them for assault after severely beating him. While this was taking place I witnessed a police officer throwing a bicycle at one of the riders who was peacefully watching from the sidewalk. The cop then charged the owner of the bike that he threw (and damaged), with assault.
(In recent months it is apparent that the Baltimore PD has no problem with violently shoving, beating or throwing a bicycle at any kind of protester downtown. Then they book you for assaulting them. They are comfortable lying under oath in a courtroom. So, keep that in mind when you join us for the next Critical Mass.)
Returning to the topic, some general thoughts about CM:
1. At its peak, around 1997 in San Francisco, several thousand bicyclists participated.
2. San Francisco arguably has the most festive rides. Many participants arrive in cheerful costumes. (One guy, known as Dildo Man, arrives costumed as a Justice League of America superhero with an erect you-know-what attached to his helmet.)
3. In Lancaster, England, CM is credited with encouraging the local government to adopt some changes that benefit bicyclists.
4. In Montreal, bicyclists in early CMs were often harassed by motorists and the police. However, eventually acceptance grew. Today altercations are fewer. (By the way, there is an interesting photo in Chris's book showing CM bicyclists in Montreal gleefully entering a large shopping mall. That must have been fun.)
5. There are never any leaders or spokespersons for the CM rides. The overall feeling is anarchistic.
The last point leads to the discussion. Is CM only to be an expression of general anarchy, a reclamation of public space by chaos? Or, should it be utilized to try to achieve specific changes in the transportation policies of major cities?
Another issue is tactics. Many people have a problem with disrupting automobile traffic. (The nay-sayers say CM should not disrupt traffic because it is a captive audience to the CM statement.) Is there moral justification for Critical Mass bicyclists to disrupt automobiles? If so, what is it?
Finally, how should CM participants react to violent outbursts by furious motorists and hysterical police?
Let's talk about it. (By the way, the next CM ride is 8/29. See ya there.)
This content is now locked, and no comments may be added.
Comments
Re: The Meaning of Critical Mass
I have participated in Critical Mass here in Baltimore off and on for the past three years. Over those years rider ship has changed from ride to ride and with that comes a different mood every time. I see nothing wrong with Critical Mass just existing as a fun way to express whatever the hell it is you want to express while at the same time joining with others to take over space, which translates into power through collective action. At the same time I do not see a problem with ideas for change being pushed behind the overall chaos inducing randomness so long as those calls for change do not become the main point to Critical Mass.
In terms of blocking traffic or not, well I don't think it would be Critical Mass if we didn't block traffic. The last ride we had we took over all lanes of traffic for most of the way until we had police intervention. At that point we decided to settle for the right hand lane and it was in no way the same. When we control the whole street the ride is calm, quiet, free from sucking on car exhaust. It truly is an enjoyable experience. When we stay in one lane leaving others open it changes the dynamic of it. It is no longer safe, no longer quite, no longer an enjoyable experience where all you hear is the normal street noise and the click of the bike wheels turning. I do, however, think we should mix up the route a bit. For the longest time now we have been going up Charles Street and down St. Paul, perhaps we could try something new next time.
The problems almost always come when we enter the larger 4 lane roads and we have to spread out. Almost like clockwork a confrontation occurs and that sends everyone scattering. I think when it comes to interacting with motorist we have to do everything within our power not to react in a violent manner. It doesn't solve anything and only makes us all look bad. Plus, it makes many of the people on the ride uncomfortable and unlikely to return next time. I think if you have a REALLY nice bike that you don't want getting run into then don't ride in the back of the ride, stay up front away from the cars. If you have a history of confrontations do the same, ride up in front of the ride and not around the cars. When you ride at the back of the ride you have to understand you will be subject to verbal abuse, and perhaps physical abuse from motorist throwing things or running into your bike with their car. Keep in mind the law is on our side in this case. If a car hits your bike hard enough to cause damage to it or yourself, then you have legal grounds to do something. At the same time if you get hit with something thrown you have legal grounds to do something. Past that, be a little understanding at their frustrations and instead of fueling it by yelling back or irritating the situation of trying to get them to hit your bike, either ignore it or drop a flyer on em. Give them something to occupy themselves.
Also, next Critical Mass meeting to discuss the next ride is Wednesday August 20 at 7:30. We will meet at the Progressive Action Center located on the corner of Gorsuch and Kirk Avenues in East Waverly
Re: The Meaning of Critical Mass
I also think that there can be no CM if we ride single file. Besides the fact that it is unsafe, it seems counterproductive to what we wish to achieve.
Furthermore, I think that aggression by motorists needs to be ignored. That's why God made helmets. Not only is likely to bring the law down on us quickly, it gives the wrong impression to onlookers.
Finally, drinking and driving doesn't mix regardless of your vehicle.
Re: The Meaning of Critical Mass
With so much public investment in these damn cars, and so much destruction being caused in their name, I think that Critical Mass is a civilized activity. Yes, the drivers are temporarily inconvenienced. However, tens of millions are definitely paying the price the rest of the time.
I can imagine future generations asking whether we did anything to stop the fossil fuel consumption of our time. CM is such an effort.
Re: The Meaning of Critical Mass
i say if you want to block off traffic and have a good time doing it, do so.. but know that the reason you are enjoying yourselves is because you are sadists.
the people that you piss off do not know that you are blocking off the road ..for the tens of millions that are suffering because of the world's thirst for oil..they think you just are a bunch of pricks and whatever message you are spitting out is going to be branded as slander in their minds.
Re: The Meaning of Critical Mass
Re: The Meaning of Critical Mass
Re: The Meaning of Critical Mass
www.allpowertothepeople.com/events/CriticalMass/
I think that the rides I have been on are mainly for the purpose of having an enjoyable bike ride. Having a nice big enjoyable bike ride draws people in. It's infectious and gets good attendance. Within that mass of cycling humanity there will be a lot of people interested in progressive causes. You can talk to them, and if you're lucky, get some young people interested in doing some other useful things.
If it gets businesses to install bike racks, people to ride bikes more, cities to think about bike planning, that's all bonus.
- Read, Black & Green -
- green.earth.al
www.Corporations-Suck.com
Re: The Meaning of Critical Mass