Baltimore IMC : http://baltimore.indymedia.org
Baltimore IMC

LOCAL News :: Gender and Sexuality

The Ehrlich Report

April has been designated as Sexual Assault Awareness month. This report, the first of three commissioned by Baltimore IMC, deals with the basic statistics of sexual assault. It will be followed by articles on domestic violence in immigrant communities and by a first-hand report of working in a battered woman's shelter.
Somewhere in the realm of the Great Calendar, a group of savants dedicated April as “Sexual Assault Awareness Month.” And why not. There is no doubt of the seriousness of the issue. Nor should there be any doubt that gender violence is an essential part of the fabric of society. The inequalities of gender, race/ethnicity, and class constitute the warp and woof of capitalism. The struggle against gender violence is a part of the struggle against all forms of inequality and oppression.

Like most men, I came to an understanding of the meaning of sexual assault fairly late. One incident stands out. It occurred while I was interviewing a woman for an article I was writing about ethnoviolence at the workplace. We had begun talking about her past encounters with violence and she began to relate to me an incident of sexual assault that had occurred almost 30 years before. I noticed as she spoke she became more animated, her face became flushed and her eyes watered. As we sat there, she was to a degree reliving that event, an event that took place 30 years before.

What is the extent of the problem? One common estimate is that physical abuse by an intimate partner ( husband, domestic partner, date, family member) is the leading cause of injury to women age 15 to 44. And while we think of homicides as majorly related to the drug trade, one criminologist has indicated that at least 25 percent of all homicides stem from domestic fights.

Let’s look at some of the hard figures provided by the National Sexual Violence Resource Center:
—In 8 out of 10 rape cases, the victim knew the perpetrator.
—Nearly 1 out 4 women may experience sexual violence by an intimate partner in their lifetime.
—One in four girls (and one in six boys) will be sexually assaulted by the age of 18.
—Among adult American women who were raped, about one-third are physically injured and only half of those injured receive medical care.
—Each year, an estimated 25,000 American women will become pregnant following a rape. As many as 22,000 of those pregnancies could be prevented through prompt emergency contraception.

There is a psychological impact of sexual assault. Depression and anxiety are common. Further there is a 50 percent likelihood that a woman will develop Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. PTSD typically involves problems of sleeping, of eating, and substance abuse. Frequently, the victim mentally relives the incident over and over.

There are monetary costs as well. The Department of Justice estimates that the health-related costs of intimate partner assault exceeds $5.8 billion each year. Eighty percent of this is for direct medical and mental health care. The remainder, about $4 billion is for the costs of lost wages and productivity.

The interpersonal tragedy of sexual assault is that it primarily involves an intimate partner. Sixty-four percent of the women who report being raped were attacked by a current or former husband, cohabiting partner, boyfriend or date. It appears, also, that women who are assaulted by an intimate partner are more likely to be seriously injured than those assaulted by other perpetrators. While men are more likely to be victims of a violent crime, women are as much as eight times more likely to be victimized by an intimate partner.
Even pregnancy is not a barrier. Over 300,000 women each year experience intimate partner violence during their pregnancy. Murder is, in fact, the leading cause of death for pregnant women.

Most of the figures come from surveys conducted over the last 10 years. While these figures may appear to be high, there is every reason to believe that they are under-stated particularly where the perpetrator is an intimate partner. Families customarily have operated in ways that are invisible to outsiders, and many women who would like to call for police assistance don’t do so because they do not want their partner arrested or incarcerated, they just want the partner to stop battering them. In general the police are not called because victims believe that the police can’t do anything or that they won’t do anything to help. When police reports are compared to personal reports in a survey, it appears that most victimizations by an intimate partner were not reported to the police.

Baltimore-based sociologist, Natalie J. Sokoloff, writing in the Women’s Studies Quarterly, provides a summary comment: “Domestic violence is part of the larger systems of violence (e.g., imperialism, racism, colonialism, patriarchy, etc) and as such domestic violence must be attacked at its root causes: the socially structured systems of inequality....We need structural solutions to structural problems.”

************************

This report will be followed in subsequent weeks by Susan Pearce on domestic violence in immigrant communities and by Jason Weller writing on his five years work experience in battered womens’ shelters.

Readers are invited to add their comments, opinions, stories to this article.
 
 

This content is now locked, and no comments may be added.

Comments

Re: The Ehrlich Report

Discussions of sexual and/or domestic assault invariably leave out 3/4 of the picture. Stats show that domestic violence is gender neutral and that DV against children is dominated by women. Not including all the facts in presumption-of-male-guilt articles only perpetuates the problem of gender violence and harm against half the population.

The massive domestic violence industry permeates government and the press, creating bad legislation and ruining families and children. As light is shed on 40 years of state-sponsored gender bias against men and fathers, articles like these can only parse the data, looking for a way to keep up the anti-male campaign.

Responsible reporting demands that the entire issue be illuminated, not just the convenient few facts that support the author's preconceptions and/or biases.
 

Re: The Ehrlich Report

“Domestic violence is part of the larger systems of violence (e.g., imperialism, racism, colonialism, patriarchy, etc) and as such domestic violence must be attacked at its root causes: the socially structured systems of inequality....We need structural solutions to structural problems.”

Nonsense. Radical gender feminism has absolutely nothing to do with equality. False claims of DV already result in some 15,000 single fathers a year taking their lives out of despair, while single mothers are "awarded" custody over 80% of the time.

Shrill feminist attacks on men ruin them; this isn't equality. Men need "structural solutions to structural problems" as much or more than anybody.
 

Re: The Ehrlich Report

Biased reports, such as The Ehrlich Report, widen the gap of hatred between the sexes and exploits all victims of sexual assault and domestic violence. Sexist propoganda by the elite feminists groups must end NOW!
 

Re: The Ehrlich Report

I think the comments above are interesting, for I've really never heard anyone argue that, and in a family structure (as a man myself), there are also psycological types of control and abuse that can occur from women that could be considered, as well as physical abuse. However, men don't have to fear walking home late at night by themselves in Baltimore in the same way women do. That's a fact.
 

Re: The Ehrlich Report

"...men don't have to fear walking home late at night by themselves in Baltimore in the same way women do. That's a fact."

No, that's an assumption. Men are some five times more likely to be murdered than women. That's a fact.
 

Re: The Ehrlich Report

Its interesting that the assumption is made that womyn walking alone at night are fearful of being murdered. Here is some info from www.pcar.org:

One study estimated that, in one 12 month period, 302,091 adult American women and 92,748 adult American men experience a completed or attempted rape. Because some persons suffer multiple rapes, it is estimated that 876,064 rapes of adult American women and 111,298 rapes of adult American men occur annually.

Granted many sexual assaults occur at the hands of someone you know, but stranger rapes do occur. I think rather than focusing in on these points we should be asking why? Why are men more likely to be murdered, and womyn more likely to be raped? What is going on in our society that perperuates these issues...and rather than arguing about statistics what can we do to change it.

Jason
 

Re: The Ehrlich Report

300,000 sexual assaults versus 100,000 murders. Also, how many of the men murdered in Baltimore are they themselves involved in violent behavior, versus sexual assaults on women who are out of that loop, so to speak. As a man, I am not afraid of walking home at 3 am, though I am not an idiot with my eyes closed either. If I was a woman, I would never do that, even armed.
 

Re: The Ehrlich Report

In looking at viewer's comments, a few points of clarification: 1). The Conflict Tactics Scale (CTS) which asks if you were ever "beaten, kicked, punched" etc. does show that women and men use these behaviors in similar numbers. What the CTS does NOT show is the CONTEXT of the behavior and WHY women and men do these things. With more in depth analysis, we find that men are much more likely to initiate the violence against women and that women are much more likely to be trying to protect themselves and responding to that violence. We also know that 85% of the people hurt in domestic violence situations are women, not men. 2. It is true that men are raped, but they are mostly raped by other men--and mostly by men who identify themselves as heterosexual men. 3. The goal should not be a numbers battle but trying to make people safe. Any man who is being abused should be helped and supported, his abuser being responsible for her or his behavior. But likewise, any woman being abused (and these numbers are much greater and more horrific usually) must have the support of her community and avaiable resources to be able to deal with that abuse. 4. It is true that men are more likely to be murdered than women--but in both cases, men and women are much more likely to be murdered by MEN--not women. Men are a danger to other men as well as to women. That should tell us something about where we need to focus our actions to make large scale social change as well as providing support and resources for individual women who are battered--and for those individual men who are also battered--by women or by other men. 5. Communities are important in trying to stop domestic violence. And as Kathryn Feltey (2001, p. 365.) argues: although woman battering occurs within individual people's lives and is expereinced as a personal event, it is "culturally produced out of intersecting relations of gender, race, social class, and sexuality." Unless we are able to make changes in these wider systems of social control and inequality, we will always be picking up the pieces of male violence--against women and against men.
 

Re: The Ehrlich Report

Anyone have tickets for the "statistics show"? I hear it has everything in it you could dream up.

Posters: If you're going to cite "statistics" name your source, as Dr. Ehrlich does. When you don't, no one pays attention to what you say. "Statistics show..." from an anonymous poster is so much farting in the wind.
 

Views

Account Login



Forgot your password?

Media Centers

 

This site made manifest by dadaIMC software